Too Many Toys, Nothing to Play With
The house is full of new toys. And somehow, no one knows what to play with. The post‑holiday overwhelm and the small reset that really helps.
My first book comes out on January 13th and this offer expires on the 12th. Preorder But I'm Bored for $28, send your receipt to ButImBored@penguinrandomhouse.com, and get 6 months of Something Playful, my paid tier of substack, for free ($30 value).
One kid whines there's "nothing to do" while half-standing on the Lego Ninjago Set they had to have. Pieces are spilling out everywhere, pieces you know you'll be finding under the couch for the next six months.
They wander from toy to toy without settling in, except to tease the two-year-old who is the only one playing with that giant set of magnetic tiles you invested in.
Your middle is half-asleep in a cardboard box in day two pajamas, with a candycane stuck to the bottom of her braid.
This is a familiar post‑holiday scene, and even when you know it’s normal, it still gets under your skin. There’s that quiet voice that wonders if you overdid it. If November‑you was overly optimistic about what new toys would solve once winter really set in.
I’ve been there, swore I wouldn’t do it again, and spoiler alert… I did.
Here’s What You’ll Find Inside This Post:
The post-holiday paradox: why a room full of new toys leads to “nothing to do” (and what’s actually happening in your child’s brain when they shut down)
The 5-5-5 reset I used with my own three kids: small decisions that reduced the noise without creating a new organizing system to maintain
Why new toys need a bridge: the strategic pairing method that helps unfamiliar toys actually get used instead of ignored
How to make the space usable again without becoming a minimalist, overhauling your life, or spending your afternoon color-coding bins
This isn’t the time for perfection- let’s just aim to make room for play.
My kids are 18, 16, and 12 now, so the toy phase has passed. (Now it’s running spikes and gear, makeup, and clothes.) But when I was parenting three kids under 7, this cycle showed up every January without fail: more stuff, less play, more chaos.
Not because the toys were wrong, but because too many options shut down play.
It’s the same feeling you get when you open a massive restaurant menu. At first, you’re hungry and excited, and then suddenly nothing sounds right. You stall. You snack on the bread. You want someone else to decide.
Kids do the same thing with toys. Add packaging they can’t open, instructions they can’t read, and everything being new at once, and avoidance makes sense.
Add in the fact that after eight straight weeks of stress-shopping, overthinking every gift, wrapping, unwrapping, cooking, cleaning, and scraping glitter off the baseboards, you’re done. It’s time to parent from the couch. You’ve earned it.
And honestly? That’s exactly what I did.
When the overwhelm peaked, I’d walk into the playroom (or the section of the living room that had clearly lost the battle) and make a few small decisions. No aesthetic reset. I did just enough to reduce the noise and get them back to play so I could get back to aimlessly scrolling and eating the leftover pie.
Here’s what that looked like:
